From School Library JournalYA?At last, Book IV of this terrific series. Set in an alternate history, Card's frontier America is a land where wives' tales are fact and magic- in the form of hexes, beseechings, and "knacks"- really works. Alvin has the most powerful knack of all; he is a Maker, with power over the physical world. In this installment, he ignores a prophetic warning and falls victim to the manipulations of The Unmaker, an ancient enemy that seeks anarchy. While embroiled in a legal dispute that places him in jail, Alvin draws to him the people who will assist in his quest to build the Crystal City of his vision. Alvin Journeyman is the springboard for this quest that will be played out in future volumes. Knowledge of previous titles is beneficial, so be sure to have copies available of Seventh Son, Red Prophet, and Prentice Alvin.?Robin Deffendall, Bull Run Regional Library, Manassas, VACopyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.From Library JournalIn an alternative 19th-century America, Alvin Smith's gift as a Maker-a rare magic that allows him to participate intimately in the act of creation-draws him into battle with the servants of the Unmaker. The fourth in a series that includes Seventh Son (St. Martin's, 1987), Red Prophet (Tor Bks., 1987), and Prentice Alvin (Tor Bks., 1987), this work explores the fundamental choice between good and evil-both the blessing and curse of humankind. The conversational tone of this engaging fantasy recalls the Silver John novels by the late Manly Wade Wellman. Card is a graceful and compassionate writer who is not afraid to tackle old-fashioned moral dilemmas from multiple viewpoints. Most libraries should consider this a priority purchase for fantasy collections.Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc. From Booklist At long last, Card returns to what promises to be his most notable creation, The Tales of Alvin Maker. In the fourth book in the series, Alvin, frontier mage in an alternate America, is in his twenties and, indeed, must go a-journeying. Driven from the Wobbish country by a girl's false accusation, he returns to his birthplace in Hatrack River and promptly finds himself on trial for stealing the golden plough from Makepiece Smith and also facing lynching for helping fugitive slaves. Meanwhile, Alvin's younger brother, Calvin, is peddling his own Maker's skills with more profit if many fewer scruples, both in America and in Europe. The book ends with Alvin's acquittal, marriage to Peggy Guester, and departure on the next stage of his quest. From beginning to end, this novel is full of riches that include Card's command of language (dialect, too!), sense of history, and vivid portraits of alternate versions of Napoleon, William Henry Harrison, Honore de Balzac, and others. This superb and welcome book continues the saga at the same high level as before, and is most highly recommended. Roland Green Review ...well-wrought characters [and] formidable scholarship in history, religi